This site is being deprecated.

Please see the official X‑Plane Support page for help.

0 votes
asked by (12 points)
edited by

This problem affects both XP10 and XP11 in my iMac with El Capitan.

I have a Logitec Attack 3 joystick to control roll, pitch and throttle and another same model joystick that I disassembled to use its electronics to build myself a pedal set assigned to control yaw. They both work perfectly, but there is a very annoying problem: X-Plane randomly assigns the joysticks to the two created configurations every time the application is started. So, often both joystick configurations are reversed. To restore the assignments, I have to either reconfigure and recalibrate the joysticks or restart X-Plane hoping this time joysticks will be correctly assigned to their configurations.

On the joystick configuration pane, both devices have identical names (Logitec Attack 3). I thought of giving each a distinctive name to try to fix the problem, but I haven't found the way to do it in the UI. I am reluctant to mess around with the joystick configuration files, so I haven't tried that.

The About This Mac's System Configuration pane shows both sticks with the same name and  product ID and with  different USB location IDs.

So, my question is: Is there a way to simultaneously use two or more joysticks of the same brand and model without having X-Plane randomly assigning each one to the wrong configuration every time the application is launched?

Thank you.

commented by (19.3k points)

X-Plane 11.10 will include new code to handle this situation as best as possible. An article about how it will work is published here.

commented by (12 points)
Thank you. Looking forward.

1 Answer

0 votes
answered by (19.3k points)
It doesn't surprise me that the sim cannot distinguish between two identical joysticks. Usually we use the name or vendor ID + product ID. However, I have forwarded it on to a developer to investigate further.
...