0 votes
asked by (31 points)
Dear all,

I try to discover running X-Plane instances by means of the "BECN" message sent out via UDP multicast. this works well on Linux, but I have no success with Windows machines running X-Plane.

I can see the UDP-multicast messages of several Linux machines using Wireshark on Linux, but I don't see any UDP-messages from the Windows machines.

Is Windows 10 somehow blocking UDP-Multicast messages? How can I make those messages come through!

I'm running out of ideas, so any help is very much aapreciated.

Cheers,

Felix

1 Answer

+1 vote
answered by (16 points)
Are your windows machines listening via wireless?

BECN message are UDP multi-cast packets which are not transmitted over wireless connections unless the wi-fi router is configured to enable Multicast-Unicast Conversion (and most home router's don't have this functionality).
commented by (31 points)

Kudos Avacii!

It really works as soon as I connect both computers to the wired connection, it works like a charm.

Do you have a pointer where I can read about the background of this behavior?

I just don't understand, why this does not work with one computer being Windows 10. When both computers run Linux, it just doesn't matter whether it's WiFi or a cabled connection. It just works. So, if you have further information on that, I'd like to learn about it.

For the moment being, I'm glad to have a workaround.

So Thanks again!

commented by (16 points)
edited by

There is also a "feature" on Windows whereby it doesn't start listening to a multi-cast group until one packet has been sent to the group. It can be 1 byte of 0x00.

My C# Xamarin code has the following:

if (RuntimeInformation.IsOSPlatform(OSPlatform.Windows))   //UWP only successfully listens to a multicast group once a packet has been sent.

                m_Client.Send(new byte[1] { 0x00 }, 1, m_MulticastAddress);

Ref: No multicast over wi-fi. The punchline is as followed. Imagine 2 clients, one connected at 11Mbps, the other at 54 Mbps,  How can a router transmit the same packet simultaneously at 2 different speeds? Hence the need for multicast to Unicast. 
This paper from the IETF details the problems: https://tools.ietf.org/id/draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement-01.html

Welcome to X-Plane Q&A, where you can ask support questions and get answers from members of the community.

This site is for X-Plane support questions only. Please search for existing answers before posting your question. Off-topic questions will be locked.

If you’re new, you’ll need to register before asking your first question.

If your question is answered, click on the check mark to select the best response.

Categories

...